TV
Episode Info  

Episode number: 4x15
Production Number: 189
Airdate: Monday February 18th, 1991


Alternate Airdates:

CA (Télé-Québec) Feb 18, 1991
IE (SETANTA IRELAND) Sep 28, 1994
FR (BBC TWO) Sep 28, 1994
United Kingdom Sep 28, 1994

 
Guest Stars
Carolyn SeymourCarolyn Seymour
As Mirasta Yale
Recurring
George HearnGeorge Hearn
As Berel
Sachi ParkerSachi Parker
As Dr. Tava
George CoeGeorge Coe
As Avel Durken
Steven Anderson (1)Steven Anderson (1)
As Dr. Nilrem
Main Cast
Patrick StewartPatrick Stewart
As Captain Jean-Luc Picard
LeVar BurtonLeVar Burton
As Lieutenant/Lt. Commander Geordi LaForge
Michael DornMichael Dorn
As Lieutenant Worf
Marina SirtisMarina Sirtis
As Counselor Deanna Troi
Episode Notes
Actress Bebe Neuwirth is more familiar to people as Frazier's icy wife Lilith on Cheers and later on Frazier.



Analysis
Deanna: Captain Picard is from a planet called Earth, which is over 2000 light years from here.

Another example of the writers failing to grasp the inadequacy of "warp drive" as it is defined: "the cube of the warp factor times the speed of light". The Enterprise has a maximum warp in the 9.5 range, but its maximum cruising (i.e., sustainable) warp is about warp 8, or 512x the speed of light. This means that in one year at this maximum warp, it could cover only 512 light years of distance. So Deanna has just indicated that this planet is almost four years travel at top speed from Earth, a place it was at only at the beginning of this fourth season. Given that it's not likely to have been four years, ship's time, since the Borg assault on Earth, clearly we have a substantial continuity/factual issue.

To express this as (presumably) at the edge of Federation space is also a problem, since that's in one direction. A sociopolitical entity which takes five to six years to "cross" (assuming for the benefit of the doubt that the expansion is asymmetrical) is generally going to have a hard time to function, and a difficult time to support its farthest reaches in the event of emergencies and so on -- so what socio-political benefit is there to be a part of said entity? It would either not expand into such a distance or it would fall apart at the first major challenge.

Clearly, the original canonical explanation of "warp factor" is inadequate to properly deal with events on the Enterprise, in any of its incarnations.



Missing Information
Click here to add Music
Click here to add Episode Quotes
Click here to add Episode Goofs
Click here to add Cultural References
Click here to add Episode References
 
Flash