| Guest Stars |
| •Agnes Moorehead | played | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Nominee | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Alfred Hitchcock | played | Best Director Nominee | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Angela Lansbury | played | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Nominee | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Barbara Stanwyck | played | Best Actress Nominee | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Bette Davis | played | Best Actress Nominee | Recurring (8th appearance) |
| •Billy Wilder | played | Best Director Nominee | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Bing Crosby | played | Best Actor Winner | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Bob Hope | played | Host | Recurring (4th appearance) |
| •Cary Grant | played | Best Actor Nominee | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Charles Boyer | played | Best Actor Nominee | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Claude Rains | played | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Nominee | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Claudette Colbert | played | Best Actress Nominee | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Clifton Webb | played | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Nominee | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Ethel Barrymore | played | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Winner | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Greer Garson | played | Best Actress Nominee | Recurring (5th appearance) |
| •Henry King | played | Best Director Nominee | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Ingrid Bergman | played | Best Actor Winner | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Jennifer Jones (1) | played | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Nominee | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Leo McCarey | played | Best Director Winner | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Monty Woolley | played | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Nominee | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Alexander Knox (2) | played | Best Actor Nominee | |
| •Aline MacMahon | played | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Nominee | |
| •Barry Fitzgerald (2) | played | Best Actor Nominee/Best Actor in a Supporting Role Winner | |
| •Hume Cronyn | played | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Nominee | |
| •John Cromwell | played | Host | |
| •Otto Preminger | played | Best Director Nominee | |
