| Guest Stars |
| •Andy Williams (1) | played | Himself - Performer | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Ann-Margret | played | Herself - Performer | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Anthony Franciosa | played | Co-Presenter: Best Sound | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Arthur Freed | played | Presenter: Irving G. Thalberg Award | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Bob Hope | played | Host | Recurring (12th appearance) |
| •Burt Lancaster | played | Presenter: Best Actress | Recurring (4th appearance) |
| •Carroll Baker | played | Co-Presenter: Best Art Direction-Set Decoration Awards | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Charles Brackett | played | Presenter: Jean Hersholt Humanitarian Award | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Cyd Charisse | played | Co-Presenter: Music Awards | Recurring (4th appearance) |
| •Debbie Reynolds | played | Presenter: Best Original Song | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Eddie Albert (1) | played | Co-Presenter: Costume Design Awards | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Eric Johnston (1) | played | Presenter: Best Foreign Language Film | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Fred Astaire | played | Presenter: Best Picture | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Gene Kelly (1) | played | Presenter: Honorary Award to Jerome Robbins | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •George Chakiris | played | Winner: Best Actor in a Supporting Role & Co-Presenter: Documentary Awards | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •George Hamilton (1) | played | Co-Presenter: Short Subjects Awards | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Gogi Grant | played | Herself - Performer | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Greer Garson | played | Herself - accepting Best Actress Award for Sophia Loren | Recurring (9th appearance) |
| •Howard Keel | played | Accepting Best Cinematography Award, Black and White for Eugen Schüfftan | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Jack Lemmon | played | Presenter: Writing Awards | Recurring (4th appearance) |
| •Joan Crawford (1) | played | Presenter: Best Actor | Recurring (6th appearance) |
| •Joanne Woodward | played | Co-Presenter: Best Sound | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Johnny Mathis | played | Himself - Performer | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Lee Remick | played | Presenter: Writing Awards | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •MacDonald Carey | played | Co-Presenter: Best Special Effects | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Maximilian Schell | played | Best Actor Winner | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Richard Chamberlain (1) | played | Co-Presenter: Best Art Direction-Set Decoration Awards | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Rita Moreno | played | Best Supporting Actress Winner | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Robert Wise (3) | played | Himself - Winner, 2 awards | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Rock Hudson | played | Presenter: Best Supporting Actress | Recurring (4th appearance) |
| •Rosalind Russell | played | Presenter: Best Director | Recurring (5th appearance) |
| •Shelley Winters | played | Co-Presenter: Cinematography Awards | Recurring (second appearance) |
| •Shirley Jones (1) | played | Presenter: Best Actor in a Supporting Role | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Tony Martin (1) | played | Co-Presenter: Music Awards | Recurring (third appearance) |
| •Vince Edwards | played | Co-Presenter: Cinematography Awards | Recurring (first appearance) |
| •Wendell Corey | played | Presenter: Honorary Award to Fred L. Metzler | Recurring (4th appearance) |
| •Abby Mann | played | Writing Award Winner | |
| •Carolyn Jones (2) | played | Co-Presenter: Documentary Awards | |
| •Dina Merrill | played | Co-Presenter: Costume Design Awards | |
| •Gene Pitney | played | Himself - Performer | |
| •Glynis Johns (1) | played | Co-Presenter: Short Subjects Awards | |
| •Jerome Robbins | played | Himself - Winner, 2 awards | |
| •Mary Costa (1) | played | Herself - Performer | |
| •Shirley Knight | played | Co-Presenter: Best Special Effects | |
| •William Inge | played | Writing Award Winner | |
