Cliff and Clair go to a meeting with Rudy's teacher after she tries to hide a letter from her teacher from them. Rudy is afraid that the letter is something bad because she believes that her teacher hates her. While at the meeting, Rudy's teacher, Mrs. Abbott, reveals that Rudy has refused to play the violin. Eventually Cliff convinces her to give it a try. Meanwhile, Theo tries to study to be a psychic so that he can pass his tests without trying.