Joe is awaiting execution in an undisclosed location. However, Ryan, Mike, and Max have a new problem: Mark and a new band of followers are restaging the deaths of Lily and her people.
Mark, Daisy, and Kyle go after someone close to Ryan in an attempt to force him, Mike, and Max to confess to their killings of Lily and the others. Meanwhile, Ryan discovers a connection between Joe and Andrew, and goes to confirm it with an unexpected source.
Ryan and his team go looking for the man responsible for Jeff's death, a trail that leads Ryan to an old friend. Meanwhile, Mark abducts two reporters, unaware that his actions are interfering with Daisy and Kyle's secret plan.
Mark, Kyle, and Daisy kill four firemen, and then go after a college student. Ryan soon realizes that the entire thing is a ploy to undermine the case against Strauss, who is going on trial for his crimes.
Ryan's credibility at Strauss' trial is undermined by the accusations against him. Meanwhile, Kyle and Daisy go after Carrie Cooke, and Mike comes face to face with Mark.
Ryan turns to Joe for help, and the killer's advice leads them to Beacon, NY. Strauss and Daisy take refuge with one of Strauss' students, waiting for another student to arrive with the fake IDs that Strauss needs to leave the country.
The FBI tries to track down Strauss' "best student," putting Max at risk. Meanwhile, Joe verbally spars with Ryan, and Tom continues to question Mike over his sacrificing Max to kill Mark.
Despite Nick's orders, Ryan follows the lead on Theo and tracks him by his fake ID. When the killer gets sloppy, Ryan and his team move in... but Theo has a surprise or two waiting for them.
-- Bring the Weight Down
While Theo tries to ruin Ryan's life, Max learns traces Mark's laptop to someone within the FBI. Meanwhile, Mark tracks down Daisy in Atlantic City and looks for revenge due to her betrayal.
Joe has one last thing to do before he's executed... and takes three hostages to make sure that Ryan comes to see him. Meanwhile, Theo rescues his sister Penny.
While Theo and Penny go looking for the person who can restore their anonymity, Ryan gets a lead on the man who may have killed Theo's parents and set him on his dark path. However, Ryan must cope with Gwen leaving him after she discovers that he's drinking again.
Ryan and Max get a lead on Penny and try to bring her in so that she can lead them to Theo. Meanwhile, Theo forces Daisy and Mark to help him breach the FBI firewall.
Ryan and Max go behind the FBI's back to trade Penny for Mike, but the plan goes wrong. Meanwhile, Lisa takes charge of the investigation, and Max learns that Tom was the mole.
Songs: Ray Noble
-- Midnight, the Stars, and You
Theo and Daisy go after someone close to Ryan in the hopes of luring him into a trap. Meanwhile, Mike hovers on the edge of death after Mark's attack.
The mole in the FBI is revealed as Max tries to find the missing Ryan. Meanwhile, Theo prepares to exact revenge for Penny's death, only to discover that Eliza and her people have their own plans.