Sarah goes on a cough-syrup bender when her sister goes on a date instead of joining her to watch their favorite TV show, “Cookie Party.”
As Jay is set to pick up a humanitarian award, Sarah attempts to outdo him by taking in a homeless person. Steve is repeatedly punched and becomes annoyed that Brian won't use his karate skills to protect him.
Sarah decides to cheer herself up by taking a HIV test but after a barrage of questions, she realizes she may have AIDS and embarks on an AIDS awareness campaign.
Sarah fails yet again in her audition for the Little Miss Rainbow Pageant but she spots a girl who she thinks can be groomed into a winner. Meanwhile, Brian and Steve become terror suspects after a phone conversation is highlighted by the FBI.
Steve pushes Brian to try something new whilst Jay's new partner leads Sarah to question her own sexuality.
Sarah is haunted by a sick kid on TV and embarks on a quest to buy batteries for her remote.
The second season opens with Sarah joining a community group for its lemon bars and discovering later that it's an antiabortion collective. Meanwhile, Steve and Brian's date night is affected by a game of Dungeons & Dragons.
Sarah decides to lick her dog Doug's rear end after watching him enthusiastically tend to his hindquarters. When the authorities are notified, Doug is taken away, leading Sarah to embark on a spiritual journey.
Sarah strongly believes that it is much easier to be a black person in America than it is to be a Jewish person. To prove her point she decides to become black for a day. Meanwhile, Brian and Steve get carried away smoking medical marijuana.
When their mother's grave is vandalized, Sarah and Laura become contestants on their favorite TV show in hopes of winning enough money to replace the tombstone.
Sarah begins dating God. She soon enough has had enough of their relationship but wants to hold out long enough to show him off at her high school reunion. Could pot smoking have turned Brian and Steve gay?
Sarah's life is spiraling out of control after she fires her maid. A trip to Mexico to find her former housekeeper ensues as she is on a quest to get her life back to normal.
Sarah gets high for the first time, and leaves herself a voicemail imploring herself to treat her stoned thoughts seriously, and to act on them. Some of these thoughts prove to be good ideas, others don't. Jay inadvertently lets the world know that he had a nocturnal emission as a result of a dream about a local news correspondent.
Sarah discovers her Russian ancestors were raped by Mongolians. Believing this has personally affected her, even 800 years after the fact, Sarah sues the entire nation of Mongolia. Steve's homemade short films get him some popularity with a demographic he'd never thought possible.
Sarah realizes her old friends aren't that much fun, so she decides to look for new ones.
While Sarah takes down an alleged terrorist, Laura's grooming habits leave a lot to be desired.
Sarah has suddenly become a bed wetter. Meanwhile, Brian discovers that Steve doesn't like his facial hair.
Sarah joins the rank of the homeless after losing her keys, but seems to like her new status after meeting an old friend who shows her the advantages of living on the streets.
Sarah cannot believe she is pregnant, and finding seems to be too much for her to handle.
Sarah finds out her dad is still alive, and after a touching family reunion they form a soft-rock cover band.
Brian and Sarah set out to coin the next big word, in hopes it will become part of society's slang terms.
The season 2 finale finds Sarah and her dog Doug, engaged to be married. But she rethinks the decision when Doug save her life. Meanwhile, an old pickle jar plays a role in Brian and Steve having a relationship renaissance.
Laura tells Sarah she was born with a penis. Mr. Jenkins returns to haunt Brian and Steve.
Sarah amuses herself by campaigning for a fake write-in mayoral candidate whom she calls, ``May Kadoody.''
Brian and Steve have a stand-off to decide who will do the laundry.
Sarah deals with various issues through scripted scenes and song.