Even though it brings up her own painful and personal memories for her, Veronica agrees, with Wallace's help, to look for the father of her classmate Justin, who has been missing for 10 years. Veronica is also having a hard time dealing with conflicting feelings she is having concerning past and present loves. Keith is called to the school by the guidance counselor who is concerned about how Veronica is handling all the changes that she has been forced to deal with lately. One of the issues that Veronica and Duncan have in common is dealing with is the upcoming anniversary of Lilly's death.