| Name (Sort) | Character (Sort) | |
| •John Cena | played | John Cena |
| •Kurt Angle | played | Kurt Angle |
| •Adam Copeland | played | Edge |
| •Mark Henry (2) | played | Mark Henry |
| •Paul Levesque | played | Triple H |
| •Oscar Gutierrez Rubio | played | Rey Mysterio Jr. |
| •Randy Orton | played | Randy Orton |
| •Shawn Michaels (1) | played | Shawn Michaels |
| •Mark Callaway | played | The Undertaker |
| •Chris Benoit | played | Chris Benoit |
| •Rob Szatkowski | played | Rob Van Dam (2001-) |
| •Michael Francis Foley | played | Mankind (1996-2000) |
| •Dusty Rhodes | played | Dusty Rhodes |
| •Glen Jacobs | played | Kane |
| •Hulk Hogan | played | "Hollywood" Hulk Hogan (1982-1992, 2002-2005) |
| •Shelton Benjamin | played | Shelton Benjamin |
| •Vince McMahon | played | Vince McMahon |
| •Bam Bam | played | Bam Bam |
| •Booker Huffman (1) | played | Booker T |
| •Chris Jericho | played | Chris Jericho |
| •Dwayne Johnson | played | The Rock |
| •Curt Hennig | played | Mr. Perfect |
| •Matt Hardy | played | Matt Hardy |
| •Shane Helms | played | Gregory Helms |
| •Ted DiBiase | played | Ted DeBiase |
| •Adnan Al-Kaissie | played | The Iron Sheik |
| •Bad News Brown | played | Bad News Brown |
| •Baron Mikel Scicluna | played | Baron Mikel Scicluna |
| •Bob Backlund | played | Bob Backlund |
| •Bruno Samartino | played | Bruno Samartino |
| •Buddy Jack Roberts | played | Buddy Jack Roberts |
| •Charlie D. Haas | played | Charlie Haas |
| •Chief Jay Strongbow | played | Chief Jay Strongbow |
| •Danny Holiday | played | Dan Basham |
| •Devon Hughes | played | D-Von Dudley |
| •Dino Bravo | played | Dino Bravo |
| •Doug Basham | played | Doug Basham |
| •Eddie Gilbert | played | Eddie Gilbert |
| •Emie Ladd (1) | played | Ernie Ladd |
| •Haku | played | Haku |
| •Haystacks Calhoun | played | Haystacks Calhoun |
| •Ivan Koloff | played | Ivan Koloff |
| •Jason Reso | played | Christian |
| •Jerry Lawler | played | Jerry "The King" Lawler |
| •Joanie Laurer | played | Chyna (1997-2001) |
| •Keith Franke | played | Adrian Adonis |
| •Kevin Nash | played | Diesal (1993-1996) (2002-2003) |
| •Lance Cade | played | Garrison Cade/ himself |
| •Mark LaMonica | played | Buh-Buh Ray Dudley |
| •Merced Solis | played | Tito Santana |
| •Michael Manna | played | Steven Richards |
| •Mil Mascaras | played | Mil Mascaras |
| •Monty Sopp | played | Billy Gunn (1993-2004) |
| •Mr. Fuji | played | Mr. Fuji |
| •Nick Dinsmore | played | Eugene |
| •Pedro Morales | played | Pedro Morales |
| •Peter Gruner (1) | played | Billy Kidman |
| •Peter Miavia | played | Peter Miavia |
| •Rene Goguen | played | Rene Dupree |
| •Rene Goulet | played | Rene Goulet |
| •Robert Howard (4) | played | Hardcore Holly |
| •Robert Marella | played | Gorilla Monsoon |
| •Salvatore Bellomo | played | Salvatore Bellomo |
| •Scott Reichsteiner | played | Scott Steiner |
| •Sean Morley | played | Val Venis |
| •Special Delivery Jones | played | "Special Delivery" Jones |
| •Swede Hansen | played | Swede Hansen |
| •Sylvan Grenier | played | Sylvian Grenier |
| •Terry Gerin | played | Rhyno |
| •The Spoiler | played | The Spoiler |
| •Tonga Fifita | played | Haku/King Haku/King Tonga |
| •Tony 'Mr. America' Marino (1) | played | Tony Marino |
| •Tony Garea | played | Tony Garea |
| •Tony Parisi | played | Tony Parisi |
| •Victor Rivera | played | Victor Rivera |
| •Andre The Giant | played | Andre The Giant |
| •Carlos Edwin Colon Coates (3) | played | Carlito |
| •Gino Brito | played | Gino Brito |
| •James Maritato | played | Nunzio |
| •Jimmy Valiant | played | Jimmy Valiant |
| •John Heidenreich | played | John Heidenreich |
| •John Layfield | played | John Bradshaw Layfield |
| •Kenzo Suzuki | played | Kenzo Suzuki |
| •Larry Zbysko | played | Larry Zbysko |
| •Mark Jindrak | played | Mark Jindrak |
| •Matt Hyson | played | Spike Dudley |
| •Matt Wiese | played | Luther Reigns |
| •Matthew Anoai | played | Rosey |
| •Mike Bucci | played | Simon Dean |
| •Orlando Jordan | played | Orlando Jordan |
| •Pat Patterson (2) | played | Pat Patterson (Pat Patterson) |
| •Paul London | played | Paul London |
| •Robert Thomas Conway, Jr. | played | Rob Conway |
| •Salvador Guerrero, Jr. | played | Chavo Guerrero Jr. |
| •Scott Garland | played | Scotty 2 Hotty |
| •Shannon Moore | played | Shannon Moore |
| •Shoichi Funaki | played | Funaki |
| •Travis Tomko | played | Tyson Tomko |
| •Trevor Rhodes | played | Trevor Murdoch |
| •Yoshihiro Tajiri | played | Yoshihiro Tajiri |