Login or register
TVRage.Com Forums => TV Talk => American Idol S12

Level 26 (74%)
Posts: 3705
Points: 1536.4
Mood: amused
Since: 20/Nov/05
Message Posted On Thursday, September 27th 2012 at 12:44 pm
The new judges:

Randy Jackson(Well, not really new.)
Mariah Carey
Nicki Minaj
Keith Urban

Anyone excited about the new panel? Well, let me start off by saying AI did great by bringing in Mariah Carey. Not only is the show gaining Mariah's fanbase, but they're also bringing a little credibility to the show with having a judge that can actually sing. The same with Keith Urban. He's a country legend. I was a little "iffy" about Nicki Minaj, but I guess she'll be a great addition. It's nice to see a Hip Hop/Rap/Pop artist brought into one of these shows.

So, how does everyone else feel about this panel of judges?
(Global Moderator)

Level 63 (94%)
Posts: 30633
Points: 6922
Since: 01/Dec/05
Message Posted On Saturday, September 29th 2012 at 2:42 pm
Didn't they just rotate in a bunch of new judges a season or two ago? Mariah Carey is a good edition, in my opinion, as she knows a thing or two about signing. Nicki Minaj.. not so much.

Level 26 (74%)
Posts: 3705
Points: 1536.4
Mood: amused
Since: 20/Nov/05
Message Posted On Wednesday, October 3rd 2012 at 11:13 am
Lol, Idol has a tendency of changing their judges. Nowadays, it's all about the judges, and not the contestants. After watching this I have lost tremendous respect for Nicki Minaj. First and foremost, she's sitting next a legend. You don't disrespect someone on Mariah's level. FOX, of course, is loving this, but Nicki better hope her career doesn't take a tumble. She hasn't been in the music industry long enough to start acting like a diva.

Level 1 (1%)
Posts: 7
Since: 19/Sep/12
Message Posted On Thursday, October 4th 2012 at 2:55 am
Randy Jackson and Mariah Carey able to be a judge and have lot of capabilities to judge any singer perfectly, always love both but i am disappointed with the selection of Nicki Minaj. She never deserves to be on the chair of judge in a most famous talent hunt show.

Level 1
Posts: 1
Since: 20/Feb/13
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 20th 2013 at 8:04 am
top 10 male!!!