Login or register  
TV
TVRage.Com Forums => TV Talk => Cartoon Wars (in movie form)
Poll Question: Eeny, meeny, miny, moe..
South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut (1999)
 
80.7% (25 votes)
Family Guy Presents: Stewie Griffin: The Untold Story (2005)
 
6.5% (2 votes)
The Simpsons Movie (2007)
 
12.9% (4 votes)
Total Votes: 31
andrew
(Forum Moderator)

Level 52 (41%)
Posts: 18192
Points: 6810.6
Mood: spinning
Since: 09/Dec/05
Message Posted On Saturday, September 8th 2007 at 9:11 pm
I voted for South Park.

Stewie Griffin: The Untold Story, didn't really feel like a movie to me. Like others have said, it felt like an extended episode. An over-rated episode, in my opinion. There's episodes of Family Guy that were better in my eyes.

The Simpsons movie was alright, but I don't know. I just felt South Park:BLU was funnier.
Donatello

Level 7 (7%)
Posts: 680
Points: 49.4
Since: 21/Sep/06
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 6:35 pm
Simpsons movie for me.

Like Dorkus hate South Park, think it's the most overrated god awful abomination ever made. Also never seen the movie so that's not even a choice for me, niether is Family Guy since I've never seen that either and I think Family Guy is highly overrated as well.
Ryan
(Global Moderator)

Level 63 (90%)
Posts: 30631
Points: 6849.4
Since: 01/Dec/05
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 6:40 pm
On Monday, September 10th 2007 6:35 pm, Donatello wrote:
Like Dorkus hate South Park, think it's the most overrated god awful abomination ever made.

Why?

And why even bother if you've never seen 2 of the 3 options?
drewshack

Level 1 (49%)
Posts: 137
Points: 5.6
Since: 06/Mar/06
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 6:59 pm
On Friday, September 7th 2007 4:14 am, Sonic_Revolution wrote:
On Thursday, September 6th 2007 9:23 pm, dorkusmcforkus wrote:
Stewie the Untold Story really didn't have a movie feel to it, so I never considered that to be a movie.. just an extended episode. But a really good episode at that.

The Simpsons movie was okay, definitely better than the episodes that have been coming out these last few seasons, but it was hardly what I'd call a great movie.

And I HATE everything South Park with a fiery passion, and strongly believe its the most over-rated show out there (behind those fugs at Greys Anatomy) so thats not even an option. Besides I've never even seen the movie in one sitting.

Sorry I added nothing to the thread.. but yeah my vote goes for The Simpsons by default I guess.

Would have been an interesting poll AFTER the Futurama film comes out later this fall... as that would definitely have my vote.


South Park is over-rated because...well, it deserves to be. Its the ONLY series of the three which has managed to retain its hilarity in all seasons of the show. Where as the new episodes of Family Guy sucks, and the old old and new new episodes of Simpsons suck.


Darn right it deserves to be! It also won the Emmy this year. South Park WoW episode wins Emmy
Donatello

Level 7 (7%)
Posts: 680
Points: 49.4
Since: 21/Sep/06
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 7:28 pm
If I don't care for 2 of the choices why would I even see the movie? Anyway everyone's entitled to their opinion, you entitled to yours as I am to mine so we don't need to turn this into a fight.
drewshack

Level 1 (49%)
Posts: 137
Points: 5.6
Since: 06/Mar/06
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 7:48 pm
On Monday, September 10th 2007 7:28 pm, Donatello wrote:
If I don't care for 2 of the choices why would I even see the movie? Anyway everyone's entitled to their opinion, you entitled to yours as I am to mine so we don't need to turn this into a fight.

Noone's trying to fight. But it is it really too much to ask 'Why?'
Ryan
(Global Moderator)

Level 63 (90%)
Posts: 30631
Points: 6849.4
Since: 01/Dec/05
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 7:51 pm
On Monday, September 10th 2007 7:28 pm, Donatello wrote:
If I don't care for 2 of the choices why would I even see the movie? Anyway everyone's entitled to their opinion, you entitled to yours as I am to mine so we don't need to turn this into a fight.

No one wants to fight. It's just there's really no need to call South Park "the most overrated god awful abomination ever made" and not give any real concrete explanation.
nishikaze

Level 24 (24%)
Posts: 6780
Points: 1155.7
Mood: None
Since: 29/Jan/06
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 9:21 pm
On Monday, September 10th 2007 7:51 pm, Ryan wrote:
On Monday, September 10th 2007 7:28 pm, Donatello wrote:
If I don't care for 2 of the choices why would I even see the movie? Anyway everyone's entitled to their opinion, you entitled to yours as I am to mine so we don't need to turn this into a fight.

No one wants to fight. It's just there's really no need to call South Park "the most overrated god awful abomination ever made" and not give any real concrete explanation.

Because the above would be trolling and more then a little inappropriate.
nishikaze

Level 24 (24%)
Posts: 6780
Points: 1155.7
Mood: None
Since: 29/Jan/06
Message Posted On Monday, September 10th 2007 at 9:25 pm
On Friday, September 7th 2007 10:12 pm, colakid12 wrote:
The Simpsons Movie was the best. South Park is a close second. South Park makes fun of Jesus, which I don't like, but I love anything about Satan being gay lovers with Sadam. Family Guy wasn't all that much of a movie. It wasn't very epic. It over-used it's ability to drop F-bombs.

Actually South Park is more disrespectful to the Church more then to Jesus. Truth be told, Jesus might be treated irreverantly at times, but it's obvious the creators have respect there.

In fact, no other character is treated with half as much respect as Jesus is.
Donatello

Level 7 (7%)
Posts: 680
Points: 49.4
Since: 21/Sep/06
Message Posted On Tuesday, September 11th 2007 at 9:03 am
I know no one wants to fight but I was just saying since I usually know when there's a disagreement between members it can result in a fight and I was trying to avoid that. Anyway about South Park I just never understood it's appeal that's all. I just don't get a show that's nothing but construction paper moving on the TV, and the overuse of vulgarity and dirty humor don't appeal to me. So I just never understood it's appeal and feel it's overrated. I'm not saying anything against the fans of course not, just attempting to state my opinion like what Dorkus did.
Ryan
(Global Moderator)

Level 63 (90%)
Posts: 30631
Points: 6849.4
Since: 01/Dec/05
Message Posted On Tuesday, September 11th 2007 at 1:44 pm
On Tuesday, September 11th 2007 9:03 am, Donatello wrote:
I know no one wants to fight but I was just saying since I usually know when there's a disagreement between members it can result in a fight and I was trying to avoid that. Anyway about South Park I just never understood it's appeal that's all. I just don't get a show that's nothing but construction paper moving on the TV, and the overuse of vulgarity and dirty humor don't appeal to me. So I just never understood it's appeal and feel it's overrated. I'm not saying anything against the fans of course not, just attempting to state my opinion like what Dorkus did.

I understand the need to voice your opinion but, like South Park apparently, you did it in quite a vulgar manner. You could have stated that you didn't understand the appeal in your original post.

As for the construction paper, eh, only the pilot episode was done using construction paper. Every single episode since the original episode has been done via computers.
Donatello

Level 7 (7%)
Posts: 680
Points: 49.4
Since: 21/Sep/06
Message Posted On Tuesday, September 11th 2007 at 1:57 pm
Sorry about that I sometimes get carried away when trying to state opinions.
1 | 2

'A Good Job: Stories of the FDNY' Press Release from HBO

A GOOD JOB: STORIES OF THE FDNY, A FILM BY LIZ GARBUS AND STEVE..

Celebrity Big Brother: George Gilby's Family Axed from Channel 4's 'Gogglebox'

It has been revealed by the Gilby familly on..

Celebrity Big Brother - Seven Face Eviction

Seven housemates face eviction after the celebrities had to nominate face to face. Gary..