For Jeff and Mika, it didn't take long for their suburban home to go from wonderful to way too small. In addition to a main floor layout consisting of too many walls, their house is struggling in several ways. The basement is damp, there is only one shower, and Jeff's passion for wine does not have a proper storage area. Wading into these troubled waters are designer Hilary and realtor David, each determined to bridge the divide between this conflicted couple. Hilary's team will be coming up with design plans and completing renovations aimed at convincing both homeowners to love this home again. David knows it's time to list and plans to cinvince the couple by showing them what other homes have to offer. In the end, will they love it or list it?