Maybe it's Me is a comedy about a family that could not be any more dysfunctional. Sixteen-year-old Molly Stage lives in a small house with her nine-member family including her free spirited parents: Jerry, the coach of a girls soccer team, and Mary, who will do just about anything to save a dime. Meanwhile, her dotty live-in grandmother likes to hide food and gets on the nerves of Molly's war veteran grandfather, by always repeating herself.
Molly's four siblings are made up of her criminal brother, Rick, her super religious other brother, Grant, who is also an aspiring Christian rocker and the terrible twins Cindy and Mindy. Molly’s efforts to be accepted by the cool kids at school tend to be thwarted by this embarrassingly odd family. At times she feels it's impossible to make it through a normal day with this outrageous clan by her side.
In the conclusion of a two-part first-season finale, Molly grudgingly goes to the prom with the nerdy son of a gangster who holds the deed to the Stage home after Rick loses it in a card game. Meanwhile, the twins try to thwart Rick's attempts to attend the dance with a sexy student.