Review: Homeland - 2.12 - "The Choice"

Damn, "Homeland." Damn. The second season has been full of ups and downs. Well done suspense has been offset (and then some) by plenty of silliness, enough that this reviewer was questioning whether he would be back for round three. And then they drop a bomb like the season finale...


Carrie and Brody find themselves back at the cabin where it all started. Carrie must make a choice: a job as station chief with the CIA or a life with Brody. The second understandably cancels out the first, given that Brody with his terrorist ties is Carrie's biggest weakness. Claire Danes is at her best this week, visibly torn up inside as her character is stuck between her sense of duty and her emotional entanglements.

Quinn's decision to not only second guess his assassination assignment but also threaten Estes should anything happen to Brody or Carrie fleshes out his character's principles as well. It's nice to see him presented as a more multi-dimensional character than "asshole spook" -- cold? Yes. Calculating? Absolutely. But with actual scruples that suggests that he could be a behind-the-scenes ally for Carrie and Brody next season.

Tonally, the first half of the episode is completely different from the rest of the season and series overall. The quiet is the most unnerving thing: little to no music, long gaps of silent understanding, everything is languidly paced while not being deliberate.

It's the veritable calm before the storm, making the sudden burst of suspense when the twist finally comes that much more effective. The explosive curveball that's thrown in the last half of the episode is an absolute game changer: not only are their some substantial deaths, but allegiances are shaken to their core, not the least of which is Saul's bond and trust in Carrie. As happy as "The Bear" was to see his protege at the end of the episode, I foresee shaky ground for this teacher/student relationship. As well done as Danes' performance is, Mandy Patinkin is a powerhouse, from his emotional message to Carrie when he fears she's dead, to his pained prayer while overlooking the 200+ victims of the bombing.

Not only will Saul and Carrie's relationship be tested next season, but despite his profession of innocence in the bombing, Brody's role remains unclear. There are numerous scenes in the finale which can be interpreted both ways, such as his talk with Mike about taking care of his family, and his crestfallen look when Carrie chose him over the job. Brody might be doing a lot more than backpacking through Canada next year.

The second season of "Homeland" has been a shaky one. For all the game-changers that were thrown at us, the well-done suspense and award-winning acting, there were an equal number of questionable choices by the writers and hamfisted melodrama from the actors. Going out on such a high note proves that when "Homeland" works, few series can do it better.

Final Grade: A

- Homeland
- Mandy Patinkin
- Claire Danes
- Damian Lewis
- Rupert Friend

Written by: kyleiam
Dec 17th, 2012, 4:07 pm


Level 1 (58%)
Since: 06/Jan/10
Message Posted On Dec 18th, 2012, 10:16 am

It seems all I am reading says this story arc is getting tedious. One season and done with it. Great acting, but now we are pushing all boundries of creditbilty to take this story into Season 3! Carrie's illness can't support all this nonsense. Please, the intelligence ground has plenty of new  script and character ideas to develop into a new season story. The writers and producers need to think again during the hiatus before they need to turn this into a Sci-Fi series to get everyone back from this plot black hole they are descending into.


Message Posted On Dec 17th, 2012, 10:12 pm
The massive amount of casualties, along with at least 1 child (VP's son) pretty much rules out Brody in my opinion. From the start he has only really held a grudge with those specifically responsible for the drone strike and as the show progressed, he became less and less interested in any sort of violence, much less against those who had no direct involvement in the strike. If it was Estes and maybe a few other key players, a case could be made for Brody's involvement, but as it stands it really seems like the only way Brody will end up being responsible is if the writers want to shove in a hamfisted twist.

Message Posted On Dec 17th, 2012, 8:49 pm
Carrie sunk to the depths of low... she aided a known terrorists escape... twice. There is no redemption for that... doesn't matter what her personal opinion in it was. Anything the writers try to do other than make her a criminal is beyond believable.. much like the entire second season has already been. Maybe they can just have her sit in a cell all next season... crying. Season one was awesome! Season two was the worse show of the year.
Related news

Chuck Goes Nude, Boardwalk Concludes, And Other TV to Have You Raging This Weekend

It's Friday, December 9th!  The weekend is finally here as the holdays..

Dexter Ends the World, And Other TV to Rage About This Weekend

It's Friday, December 16th!  The weekend is finally here as the holdays..

Writers Guild Award Winners Include Breaking Bad, Homeland

The Writers Guild Awards were handed out Sunday night, and while the..
Discuss Homeland