Review: 'Hemlock Grove' premiere reveals there’s nothing original about Netflix’s latest “original” series

Hemlock Grove

The best thing I can say about the premiere of Netflix’s new original series Hemlock Grove is that it is unfocused. Is it a murder mystery, science fiction, horror or fantasy/supernatural? One of the problems I have with the series is that I think it is trying to be a little bit of everything and winds up being nothing noteworthy at all. It jumps back and forth between the present and past, quickly introduces a wide variety of characters, some of whom are obviously not completely human. Hemlock Grove goes to great lengths to stand out from its Twilight-like brethren but the show still gives off that been there done that vibe.

The episode begins with the brutal murder of a local teenage girl named Brooke Bluebell (Lorenza Izzo), who is not the stereotypical high school cheerleader she seems to be at first glance. Not only does she appear to be having a sexual relationship with a female science teacher, but she also has some connection to Roman Godfrey (Bill Skarsgard), a member of the town’s most prominent family. On the way to a liaison with Banksy, an apparent nickname or code that Brooke  and her teacher developed to help maintain secrecy, the girl is viciously attacked a killed by some sort of animal, presumably a werewolf. This isn’t your MTV Teen Wolf variety of the beast. Although the creature doesn’t appear in the premier episode, what remains of Brooke points to something more closely resembling the bloodthirsty wolf in The Howling.

After Brooke’s murder, the episode flashes back to “earlier in the summer,” when Lynda Rumancek (Lily Taylor) and her son Peter (Landon Liboiron) arrive in Hemlock Grove. They’ve inherited a run-down trailer from a relative who, judging by the vials of fluid found by Lynda, was into something nefarious. Their presence is immediately noticed by Christina Wendall (Freya Tingley). She identifies Peter as a gypsy, which in Hemlock Grove, is considered one, if not, the lowest of the low on the social ladder. Christina also asks whether he worships the devil after spotting pentagram carved into a nearby tree and questions if he is a werewolf as well. Not really standard questions when getting to know the new kid in town.

In another more affluent home, Olivia Godfrey (Famke Janssen) wakes her son Roman. Her look and demeanor is reminiscent of Morticia Addams meets Michelle Pfieffer’s Elizabeth Collins Stoddard from Dark Shadows. Her accent is indistinct or more specifically nonsensical with the exception of the occasional British lilt that creeps in every now and again. In another flashback, viewers learn that Olivia’s husband JR (Paul Popowich) has discovered his bride to be some incarnation of evil and kills himself as a result. JR’s brother Norman (Dougray Scott) is head of the family business, a stand-in patriarch of his brother’s family as well as the head of his own. Norman’s daughter Letha (Penelope Mitchell) aside from being perky and blonde is very close to her brooding, degenerate cousin.

The first day of school begins, and there is an odd, non-verbal interaction between Peter and Roman. Even though it is the first time they have laid eyes on one another, there is a feeling of familiarity between them, as if they know each other’s darkest secrets. Peter runs into Christina and is affable, but she is dismissive; far from the curious creature she was at their initial meeting. Roman witnesses their interaction with interest. Things only get stranger for Peter. As he stands at his locker, a large, hulking girl comes wheezing down the hallway. Her combat boots shuffle along the floor. Her face isn’t visible because she hangs her head low and her hair acts as a shield. For a brief moment, it seems as if a light is glowing around her face. A few girls make fun of her Frankenstein-like gait but she seems impervious to their impression. She is warmly greeted by her brother, who happens to be Roman. Later, the audience gets to see that she is severely deformed.

Peter, Roman and Letha

In yet another flashback, we learn her name is Shelley (Olivia Boivin), and she is anything but daddy’s little girl. He thinks this abomination is his punishment for bringing Olivia, who he no longer believes to be a woman, into their family. JR confides in his brother that he could find no evidence of Olivia’s lineage, not one single relative. He asks Norman to help him destroy her, but Norman dismisses his brother’s suspicions and suggests he come to stay with his family for a while. JR then says to his brother that he knows Norman is sleeping with Olivia.

Hemlock Grove is dark, gory and salacious but not in a good way like HBO’s True Blood and not in a campy, funny way like Burton’s Dark Shadows. The show borrows from Rosemary’s Baby, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Carnivale, Stephen King and Ray Bradbury. I have no doubt the writers will develop their own mythology and that the mystic town of Hemlock Grove will strive to not adhere to the vampire, werewolf and witch trifecta. The show may develop a cult following for those who think TV shows that fall into the horror/fantasy genre are too G-rated, too watered down to appeal to the masses. But the bottom line is that the show just isn’t good. And no amount of gimmicks can change that fact. The creators obviously tried hard to cram the premiere with enough oddities and intrigue to entice viewers to eagerly devour the next episode. Perhaps, the only good news about Hemlock Grove is that if it manages to garner any fans, they can watch all 13 episodes in one sitting.

- Netflix
- Hemlock Grove

Written by: zappalicious
Apr 19th, 2013, 11:11 am

Images courtesy of Netflix


Message Posted On May 15th, 2013, 5:42 pm
It's baffling this is a review and you don't even have the fats straight anyways.. Peter and Lynda arrived before the Brooke girl was killed. Been there done that? Funny, I didn't get that vibe I liked it have NEVER seen anything like it and trust me I've watched ALOT of vamp/wolf/supernatural shows. And anyways it has HOT guys in it, girls will watch! Bill Skarsgard is Smokin' !

Message Posted On Apr 28th, 2013, 6:57 am
I finally have watched and read this horrible "review" I think the show is just crazy, random and whatever else. I hope it succeeds I like the way of delivering tele by netflix like this. I read an article about eli and whoever else about how netflix can see on demand who and how many people have watched what, and stats. etc. I think this is great, as the article said also, is that you don't have to sit and watch weeks you can watch every ep and go.

Message Posted On Apr 23rd, 2013, 3:22 pm
I like the show, the storyline and the casting. I wish it could improve the script as for the lines delivered. They can be a bit on the cheesy side from time to time.

Level 3 (38%)
Since: 12/Mar/13
Message Posted On Apr 22nd, 2013, 8:07 am

I mean real horror. TVD, The Following (more like serial killer parody this one) etc are not horror. American Horror Story, Hannibal - that's what I call horror. Cold, dark, creepy.


Level 1 (69%)
Mood: aggravated
Since: 02/Feb/13
Message Posted On Apr 22nd, 2013, 5:55 am

Lack horror shows? ;p There's more than ever inc these days ;)

M. Lee

Message Posted On Apr 20th, 2013, 1:16 pm
Why not pick what category thus show is in? Let the viewers choose. But I do agree with you on the flashback; but that's all I agree on your opinion of the show.

Message Posted On Apr 19th, 2013, 4:52 pm
Are you high? I think the show was wonderful.

Level 3 (38%)
Since: 12/Mar/13
Message Posted On Apr 19th, 2013, 3:30 pm

I think should be awesome series. We lack of horror series, there are really too little of them. When I have the chance I'll watch it, as NetFlix is not available in my country. And no offense, but woman reviewing violent/horror story, in my experience it's never good.


Message Posted On Apr 19th, 2013, 12:30 pm
I been interested in this, it sounded really violent and thrilling. I will try to take time to watch it tonight or so, will reply back once I watch it.
Related news

Don’t Trust the B----- in Apt. 23: The Verdict is Out

  The Ratings are holding up so far for Don’t Trust the B----- in..

REVIEW: 'The Mob Doctor' is Better than Expected

I went in to the first episode of 'The Mob Doctor' with low expectations...

REVIEW: 'Partners' is Terrible

Look up any of the promotional material or reviews for CBS' new sitcom..