Bad 'American Idol' finale rating draws criticism - "It’s become your grandparents’ American Idol."



The ratings have come in for American Idol's season 12 finale and the news is not good. The program lost more than 40 percent of its audience from last season's finale, which was about 7 million viwers. The show drew a disappointing 3.6 rating in the adults 18-49 demographic, with 14.3 million viewers total. 

Never before had an American Idol finale not done at least 20-million viewers. S.O.S., captain, the ship is sinking!

Brad Adgate, Horizon Media senior vice president of research, believes he knows what went wrong. He says that the average age of Idol viewers is more than 51 (!) years old, an increase of nearly 4 years from only two seasons ago. 

 “The numbers are headed in the wrong direction,” he said. “If the show got 10 million viewers and the median age was 32, I don’t think advertisers would mind that. But it’s become your grandparents’ American Idol.

I am pretty sure Fox did not use that quote at its upfront this week.

Adgate says that The Voice and The X Factor have really hurt American Idol.

“What made Idol so special was its limited supply,” he said.  “And to its credit, Fox didn’t succumb to the financial pressures of running the show in the Fall. But to keep Simon Cowell happy, it created a spin-off series and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that once it came in, you started to see this significant downfall for Idol. … In two years, Idol’s average audience has dropped by 10 million viewers, from 23.1 million viewers to 13.2 million.

“Buyers are not going to be tripping over themselves like they had been about paying a premium ad rate for Idol,” he added. “Sure, it’s a top 10 show this year, but with young viewers leaving en masse and next year’s judges up in the air…” 

What do you think?

- American Idol

Written by: Hamatosan
May 17th, 2013, 8:05 pm

Images courtesy of FOX


Level 1 (5%)
Since: 21/Mar/13
Message Posted On May 19th, 2013, 10:18 pm

I'm in the over 50 group and I only watch a few of the highlights from YouTube clips.  The last time I actually sat through a whole season was when I was dating the cousin of one of the contestants and I hated it which may be why I'm not dating her anymore.  This "reality" show has always been over hyped and over dramatized.  Maybe this is a good sign.  Maybe the next generation is actually smarter than we were.


Message Posted On May 18th, 2013, 3:27 am
Nobody watched because everyone knew who was going to win, if the results weren't fixed. The demographic of shows will always change. People get older and still like the show, so keep watching. This move to alienate viewers by pushing for a young audience is retarded. Just bin the show and start fresh if you want a younger audience.
Related news

X Factor Double Elimination: Who got the boot?

"X Factor" broke hearts last night as two of the top seven went home. In a..

Glee Knows its ABCs

Glee was intense last night as New Directions went up against rivals the..

Ryan Seacrest Meets With "Today Show" Producers

Ryan Seacrest in constantly unveiling new projects as producer,..