When the Bennett’s arrive at the church to help decorate for Christmas, Simone looks at Kay's brooch. When she sees Miguel’s face in it, she promptly tells her to get rid of it, saying that it is evil. In the basement, the Little Angel Girl appears to Charity, causing her to get scared. Elsewhere, Theresa falls off a ladder and is caught by Ethan. When he talks about love, she thinks he’s talking about her, unaware that Gwen is the woman of his dreams. In New Mexico, before Luis confronts his father, he gets a surprise when he finds Julian nearby.