<-- Previous EpisodeNext Episode -->
Phillip makes the decision to leave the Legacy once and for all but takes on one last case as a favor for a Monseignor at a private Catholic school. A teacher has disappeared, a new Substitute has appeared out of no where and the Ledgerdemain club has been resurrected with the help of said subsistute teacher. Three teenage boys know the truth that underlies the teacher's disappearance but don't speak out of fear. Phillip and Nick must come up with clues on their own and fight the evil presence's hold in order to save all involved.