Beth is frantic to find a Cannibal Caveman for Willie after he says it's the only toy he wants this year. But the stores are all sold out due to their popularity. Beth learns that there is a shipment coming on Christmas Eve and asks Dave to stop and pick one up while he shops for her gift. Dave discovers his license has expired and stops to get it renewed, but because of an infraction he must retake a driving test. Meanwhile, Shel is heartbroken that Estelle has taken Carly to Aspen for the holidays and Kenny is preparing for his own ski trip while Mia directs a local play of the Nativity.