The lives of three teens (Taylor; Olivia; Kolby) whose parents are pastors are chronicled. In the opener: Taylor reveals a fantasy; Olivia questions the paternity of her daughter; and Kolby asks her parents for permission to start dating.
Olivia gets the results of a paternity test; Taylor lies to her parents and attends a party with boys; Kolby's sister Teryn makes a shocking confession.
Kolby questions her beliefs about premarital sex; Olivia meets with a lawyer after she contacts her baby's father; Taylor meets a new boy.
Nikita's daughters help him to rekindle his relationship with Victoria; Taylor goes on a double date with her parents; Olivia introduces her parents to a boy from her past.
Nikita and Victoria go on date for the first time in seven years, which leads Kolby to rethink her relationship with Micah. Meanwhile, Olivia discovers a secret about Frankie; and Taylor's dad suffers a health scare.
Olivia wants to take her daughter trick-or-treating on Halloween, but her parents are against it. Meanwhile, Kolby celebrates her first Halloween with a house party; and Taylor and Marie try to keep the church going while Ken is in the hospital.
Marie makes Taylor attend a class on purity at church; Olivia visits her sister in Los Angeles and takes part in a sexy photo shoot; Kolby and her sisters experience a wild weekend.
Olivia leads an outing for troubled teens; Ken and Taylor visit a Christian college; Victoria shares a secret with Kolby.
Ken and Marie throw Taylor an 18th birthday party, but things get wild as the night goes on. Meanwhile, Victoria loosens the reins on Kolby dating; and Olivia worries that her partying past could have lasting effects on her daughter.
The Perrys, Colemans and Koloffs recall highlights from the first season.