Michael and Joey were once best friends. However, the two lost touch when they quarreled over a girl. They are reunited for the reading of her will and discover they have been granted joint custody of her daughter. Which of the two is the father? The judge declares they both are.
When Michael forces the family to move to his apartment, Joey has difficulty fitting into uptown life, and Nicole has no playmates in their new building.
The dads must deal with Nicole when she and a friend go to the movies... in New Jersey.
Joey prepares Nicole for her first date. Unfortunately, his lecture didn't prepare her for being stood up.
Nicole sets Michael up with a neighbor. He finds the situation confusing when he can't decide if they're dating or just friends.
When both dads have dates, they decide to let Nicole stay home alone with her friends.
Joey makes a deal with his father. He'll join the family plumbing business if his art doesn't sell at an upcoming one-man show.
Michael gets a date with a woman that turned Joey down. Unfortunately, the woman is Judge Wilbur's engaged niece.
When Nicole has a failing grade in art, Joey rushes to her defense. He ends up dating the teacher, something that makes Nicole very unhappy.
Michael suffers from guilt when business forces him to cancel dates with Nicole.
Joey and Michael are excited to celebrate their first Christmas with Nicole. Unfortunately, she wants to ignore the holiday because it will be her first without her mom.
Nicole misses being the center of attention when her dads fulfill her wish for a little brother.
When Michael's mom comes for a visit, she makes Joey miserable and stops Nicole from seeing Cory.
Upset and worried when Michael ends up in the hospital after training, Nicole demands the loft's racquetball championship be cancelled.
Joey's rock star friend visits. He believes Michael has been a bad influence on Joey.
Things get complicated around the house when Nicole's best friend falls in love ... with one of Nicole's dads.
Michael decides to date again, but his dating life is thown off when he finds out that he's dating Nicole's boyfriend's mother.