The babysitters decide to give their most vivid memory. Stacey explains her hard time about fiting in New York. Claudia talks about the time she did not listen to her art teacher's instructions. Mallory explains the day she met her favorite author. Jessi tells her's about when they were having a new baby. Logan explains his life when he met Mary Anne. Shannon tells her memory about meeting Kristy. Kristy explains her memory when her father left her family. Mary Anne explains when her baby-sitter played a trick on her.