When a psychic tells Bella that she's already dated the man she is meant to marry, she makes a list of her exes and sets out to find her destiny.
Bella reconnects with Jake, a former couch potato turned fitness freak, who plans various strenuous activities for their dates to prove he's changed. Meanwhile, Cyrus makes up a drinking game in which the gang must "google" their exes.
After being robbed, Bella agrees to go on a date with the police officer who responds to the scene of the crime. The police officer, Ronny, is an ex-boyfriend who Bella's father hated because of his "bad boy" image. Worried that it was her dad's fault that they broke up, Bella decides to give Ronny another try.
Bella runs into Jake, an ex-boyfriend with whom she broke up because he refused to move out of his mother's house. However, when Bella learns he's finally moved out, she agrees to go on another date with him.