Login or register  

Review: Elementary 1.04 "The Rat Race"

After a disappointing low point last week, "Elementary" bounces back in a huge way with its fourth episode "The Rat Race."

Holmes steals Watson away from an ambush lunch date set up by an old friend, as he has been summoned to an emergency meeting revolving around the disappearance of an investment firm COO. Sherlock's observational skills are given a new dimension this week, as he expresses his disdain for his employers and their greedy self interests while gleefully overcharging them for his services. COO Peter Talbot unexpectedly no-showed an important quarterly conference call with investors, prompting the company's upper crust to grow concerned that this may lead to negative speculation and a stock drop.

Surveying Talbot's office, Holmes notes the shelves full of unread books, the spine cracked and weathered on only one: a hollowed out book which hides a high-end prostitute catalog. Further prying unearths the COO's secret apartment and Talbott himself -- overdosed on heroin, a drug we learn is "one of" the drugs that sent Holmes to rehab in the first place.

An interview with Talbott's wife elicits a seemingly harmless comment about the accidental death of Talbott's predecessor. While Gregson and his department see a simple accidental overdose, Holmes sees a trail of suspicious deaths within the company's upper crust, deducing that the killer is a sociopathic ladder climber.

As strong as the case is this week, it's really secondary to the stellar character development. Holmes' background is the real meat of the episode, as the mystery behind the overdosed corporate executive sheds some light on the consultant's own addiction recovery. Miller's performance is exceptional this week, depicting Holmes' tough outer shell slowly crumbling as his past is revealed to his friend and colleague Gregson, all while he also deals with internal strife after being confronted with his vice.

Watson and Holmes' relationship is expanded on even more. Sherlock's worldview is rubbing off on his sober companion, as after Joan's friend sets her up on a blind date, she uses her newly acquired deductive skills to reveal her date lied about his marital status. Her concern with Holmes at the OD crime scene, as well as the pair's shared scenes at the end of the episode, exudes a chemistry between the two actors that had barely shone through in previous episodes. As if that weren't enough, Gregson and Holmes' own bond is tested when Sherlock is forced to come clean about his addictive past in a genuinely emotional scene. It's all top-notch, and a welcome return to form after the awful third episode.

Hopefully, "The Rat Race" is a sign of things to come for the series. The police procedural has been done to death, but mysteries serving as catalysts to expand on Holmes, Watson, and Gregson's colorful pasts is rife with potential, as this week's episode shows.

Final Grade: A+

- Jonny Lee Miller
- Lucy Liu
- Elementary

Written by: kyleiam
Oct 26th, 2012, 4:19 am


Message Posted On Oct 26th, 2012, 8:42 am
Great, grade-A+ episode, for all the reasons stated (no kids hurt, bankers humiliated - what more can we ask?). *** Seeing a more vulnerable Holmes (vis-a-vis Capt. Gregson) was a special treat.
(Data Entry Specialist)

Level 67 (98%)
Points: 51122.4
Mood: apathetic
Since: 12/Jan/08
Message Posted On Oct 26th, 2012, 5:28 am

I agree with your analysis of this episode, it was top notch. When I first heard about an American version of the Sherlock Holmes story, I had my doubts, but I have been pleasantly surprised. I am so tired of the CSI/NCIS shlock that passes for entertainment on broadcast tv.

Related news

Sherlock Holmes Season 2 Teasers

The BBC’s man Sherlock Holmes returns shortly to UK television sets...

Sky Announces latest US imports

Sky has announced it's latest America acquistions, with four upcoming..

CBS Unveils Posters for New Fall Shows

CBS has four major new drama shows headed to the network this fall, and on..
Discuss Elementary