Login or register  

Review: Erratic 'Black Box' Another Procedural About a Brilliant Rogue Doctor, But Poorly Done


Review: Erratic 'Black Box' Another Procedural About a Brilliant, Rogue Doctor But Done Poorly


For a show about the mind, ‘Black Box’ surely lacks imagination. On the surface it’s a procedural following the professional and personal life of neurologist Dr. Catherine Black, however it quickly and unfortunately becomes a familiar and eye-rolling tale of sex scandals, office romance, gossipy co-workers, and poorly-executed exposition.

The twist here in this hour-long drama is that Dr. Black, who is lauded as the Marco Polo of the brain (the brain is known as "The Black Box," and her name is Black, get it?!), is bi-polar and has kept this her little secret. That means that in the pilot, she is recounting a story with her psychiatrist (Vanessa Redgrave) in which she goes off her meds, hallucinates, has passionate sex with a random guy, and then comes down hard afterward.

Kelly Reilly is the titular Black, a luminous, graceful presence who unfortunately is subject to typical television, well, boxes. While apparently impressively capable at her job, she is awkward and mostly hopeless when it comes to love. She has fortunately found a patient, caring boyfriend in a handsome chef (David Ajala), but she lies to and cheats on him, acting petty then mature then petty again.

While the personal side of things is contrived – she also has a combative sister and adoring niece, and that’s its own little story with an utterly predictable twist – the professional world is generic at best and completely absurd at worst.

Review: Erratic 'Black Box' Another Procedural About a Brilliant, Rogue Doctor But Done Poorly

Part of it is the presence of Dr. Ian Bickman (Ditch Davey), a suave, cocky, ladies man of a new neurosurgeon who oozes creepiness, solicits publicity, and loves to be the rogue. You watch him cartry on just waiting for Davey to wink at the camera, but he never does.

In one ridiculous instance, he chastises a fellow doctor during a surgery using the show’s favorite word, "douche bag." The surgeon in turn storms out, leaving a patient at risk. It’s not until others tell Bickman he shouldn’t do anything that he does something. “It’s only childbirth, not brain surgery,” he retorts with a line that may or may not have been the reason for the entire scene.

It seems too that all the men Dr. Black encounters professionally look down at her or just disagree with how she works. She's regarded as too headstrong and too emotional. The only ones who look up to her are young women, but that’s because they need to be taught.

I suppose though it’s all meant to be played as this smoky, surreal romantic saga, as for reasons unknown, a jazz soundtrack underscores every scene in this soapy melodrama. The drama is absurd while the comedy, what little attempts there are, feel forced. Reilly could definitely act the part of the sultry lounge singer, and she could too be a world renowned neurologist – she just doesn’t have the material.

Review: Erratic 'Black Box' Another Procedural About a Brilliant, Rogue Doctor But Done Poorly

Much of the time is spent oscillating awkwardly between the personal and personal, regressing and rehashing the same stories. What’s more it’s blatantly egregious how poor the exposition is, as writers fabricate the most artificial of encounters to explain new characters, diagnoses, or procedures to the audience.

Despite a compelling lead actress and a simple framework that could allow for some interesting stories that could serve to inform and elucidate mental illness, ‘Black Box’ is another series about a brilliant yet plagued doctor that clashes with colleagues while saving lives. It’s that, and it also wants to be a series about torrid romantic affairs, but that doesn’t work either.

“You’ve only seen one side of me; I can be such a bitch,” Black tells her boyfriend early on in the pilot when he asks her to marry him. It’s one of the many overt, dumb-downed phrases in a show that spells everything out to the audience.

It is accurate though, as Black does show various extreme sides to her personality. If only the show had anything under its surface that was as compelling.

- Kelly Reilly
- Black Box (ABC)

Written by: AnthonyWrites
Apr 24th, 2014, 5:56 am

Images courtesy of ABC


Level 2 (86%)
Since: 13/Feb/13
Message Posted On May 1st, 2014, 10:04 am

I've just watched a pilot and it was bad.


Message Posted On Apr 25th, 2014, 7:09 pm
SO... black box negro hookers.... uh, flake? THAT seems to you THINNLY VEILED?? you are a MORON. the joke just wasn't funny but who cares? thinly veiled... hahahahahahahaha, now THAT'S hilarious

Message Posted On Apr 25th, 2014, 6:08 pm
Even Homeland is a bit overdone but it gets the closest to showing the feeling invincible manic side and well as the hopelessly depressed side. The again it's one of the best shows to have ever been done so that just par for the course. One thing Homeland could do better is that the duration is not always consistent. Carrie seems to go only through long periods but it's not always that way. One can swing in hours or one can swing in days, etc. Another thing it misses it that both sides can be creative periods not just the manic one.

Message Posted On Apr 25th, 2014, 5:59 pm
If that were her response when I asked the I tell her to forget it. You obviously only care about making excuses. Go grow up, Ms Black.

Message Posted On Apr 25th, 2014, 2:09 am
Mmm. Kelly Reilly, Vanessa Redgrave, David Ajala, Ditch Davey.... for an American show it seems to lack one thing....
Jake The Flake

Message Posted On Apr 25th, 2014, 12:14 am
If you class racism as humour Anonymous that's your prerogative. Like most people who post derogatory comments on sites like this you thrive on the negative responses. If not being racist makes me humourless to you so be it, I'm quite happy not to sink to your level of so called humour.

Message Posted On Apr 24th, 2014, 11:33 pm
Loora, Next time find someone smarter than you to reply. That post looked as if you simply strung buzzwords together. Buzzwords you didn't comprehend.

Level 1 (3%)
Since: 14/Apr/14
Message Posted On Apr 24th, 2014, 5:24 pm

Bi-polar disorder is so poorly treated in television. It really is not a realistic representation at all.


Message Posted On Apr 24th, 2014, 3:09 pm
That's not humor, it's blatant overexposure to dirt cheap american pr0n talking through a young white males mouth.

Message Posted On Apr 24th, 2014, 11:50 am
Jake The Flake, Humorless prude.
Related news

Once Upon a Time has Character Roots from Lost

The story for Once Upon a Time was spun eight years ago while Adam..

Once Upon a Time Reveals the Truth About Sexy Sheriff

This weeks teaser for Once Upon a Time may reveal too much about..

Jennifer Beals Joins ABC "Castle" For Two Episodes

This season’s “Castle” has shown us a different side of Castle and..