| •Mike Tenay | played | Himself (Commentator - 2004 - ?) |
| •Peter Senerchia | played | Taz (Commentator - 2009 - ?) |
| •Don West | played | Himself (Commentator - 2004 - 2009 / Director of Merchandise/Sales - 2010 - 2012) |
| •Jeremy Borash | played | Himself (Backstage Interviewer - 2004 - ?) |
| •Dixie Carter (2) | played | Herself (CEO, Co-Owner & President of TNA - 2002 - ?) |
| •Christy Hemme | played | Christie Hemme / Christy Hemme (Backstage interviewer & Ring Announcer - 2006 - ?) |
| •Santana Garrett | played | Brittany (2010 / March 2013 - ?) |
| •Taryn Terrell | played | Herself (2012 - ?) |
| •Seiya Sanada | played | Sanada (9 March 2014 - ?) |
| •Tigre Uno | played | Himself |
| •Tanea Brooks | played | Rebel (May 2014 - ?) |
| •Antonio Banks | played | Antonio Banks / Montel Vontavious Porter / MVP - Investor & 1/2 Owner (April 2003 - August 2004 / 30 January 2014 - ?) |
| •Davey Richards | played | Himself (February 2014 - ?) |
| •Eddie Edwards (2) | played | Himself (February 2014 - ?) |
| •Eric Parks | played | Abyss / Mr. Joseph Park, Esq. (2004 - January 2012 / March 2012 - ?) |
| •Allen Jones (1) | played | 'The Phenomenal' A. J. Styles (2004 - 2014) |
| •Michael Hutter | played | Ethan Carter III (October 2013 - ?) |
| •Thomas Latimer | played | Bram (2014 - ?) |
| •Jeff Hardy | played | Jeff Hardy / "The Charismatic Enigma" Jeff Hardy / Willow (2004 - 2006 / January 2010 - March 2011, August 2011 - 11 February 2014 / 9 March 2014 - ?) |
| •Jessicka Havok | played | Havok (2014 - ?) |
| •Matt Hardy | played | Himself (January 2011 - August 2011 / 2014 - ?) |
| •Marie Kristin Gabert | played | Alpha Female (February 2014 - ?) |
| •Joe Seannoa | played | Samoa Joe (2005 - ?) |
| •Kurt Angle | played | Himself (2006 - ?) |
| •Bobby Roode | played | Bobby Roode (2004 - ?) |
| •James Storm (2) | played | 'Cowboy' James Storm (2004 - ?) |
| •Christopher Daniels | played | 'The Fallen Angel' Christopher Daniels / Curry Man / Suicide / Daniels (2004 - 2008 / 2008 / 2009 / 2010 - 2014) |
| •Shannon Moore | played | 'Prince of Punk' Shannon Moore (2005 - 2006 / 2010 - 2012) |
| •Brooke Adams (2) | played | Miss Tessmacher / Brooke Tessmacher (2009 - ?) |
| •Brian Gerard James | played | B. G. James (2004 - 2009) |
| •Monty Sopp | played | Kip James (2005 - 2009) |
| •George Murdoch | played | Tyrus (2014 - ?) |
| •Steve Scott (3) | played | Crazzy Steve (2014 - ?) |
| •Frankie Kazarian | played | Himself / Kaz / SUICIDE / Kazarian (2004 - 2005 / 2006 - 2008 / 2008 - 2009 / 2010 - 2014) |
| •Petey Williams | played | Himself (2004 - 2009 / 2013) |
| •Jeremy Fritz | played | Eric Young / Super Eric (2004 - 2008 / 2008 - ?) |
| •Patrick Martin | played | Alex Shelley (2004 - 2012) |
| •Elix Skipper | played | 'Primetime' Elix Skipper (2004 - 2007) |
| •Michael Paris | played | Zema Ion / DJ Z (June 2011 - 2014 / 2014 - ?) |
| •Hawk Younkins | played | Hawk (2006) |
| •Madison Rayne | played | Herself (2009 - ?) |
| •Josh Harter | played | Chris Sabin (2004 - 2014) |
| •Rudy Charles | played | Himself - Referee (2004 - 2006 / 2008) |
| •Shawn Hernandez | played | 'Hotstuff' Hernandez / Hernandez (2003 - September 2004 / March 2006 - 2014) |
| •Mathew Bentley | played | Michael Shane / Matt Bentley / Martyr (2004 - 2005 / 2005 - 2007 / 2007) |
| •Jeff Hammond | played | Himself (2005) |
| •Vince Russo | played | Himself - Director of Authority / Booker (2004 / 2006 - ?) |
| •Mark "Slick" Johnson | played | Himself - Referee (2004 - 2006 / 2008) |
| •Tony Martin (3) | played | Shane Douglas / Road agent (2004 - 2006 / 2006 - ?) |
| •David Cash | played | Kid Kash (2002 - 2005, 2010 & July 2011 - ?) |
| •Lance Hoyt | played | Dallas / Lance Hoyt / Lance Rock (2004 / 2005 - ?) |
| •Mickie James | played | Alexis Laree / Mickie James (2003 / 2011 - ?) |
| •Tracy Brookshaw | played | Traci Brooks / Miss Brooks / Tracy Brooks (2004 - 2006 / 2006 - 2007 / 2007 - ?) |
| •Moon Shadow | played | Goldylocks / Goldy Locks (2004) |
| •Scott Levy | played | Raven (2004 - 2008 / 2009 - ?) |
| •Jessie Godderz | played | Himself (August 2011 - ?) |
| •Jesus Martínez | played | El Zorro (September 2011) |
| •David Penzer | played | Himself - Ring Announcer (2006 - ?) |
| •Retesh Bhalla | played | Sonjay Dutt (2004 - ?) |
| •Mikey Batts | played | Himself (2004 - 2005) |
| •Jerrelle Clark | played | Himself (2004 - 2006) |
| •Jonathan Figueroa | played | Amazing Red (2004 - 2005 / 2009 - ?) |
| •Mike Posey | played | Himself - Referee (2004 - 2005) |
| •Brooke Hogan | played | Herself (May 2012 - August 2013) |
| •Terry Brunk | played | Sabu (2004 - 2006) |
| •Chad Collyer | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Kyle McNeely | played | Onyx (2004) |
| •Dean Roll | played | Shark Boy (2004 - ?) |
| •Gail Kim | played | Herself (2005 - ?) |
| •Muhammed Lawal | played | King Mo (May 2012 - present) |
| •Johnny Devine | played | 'Hotshot' Johnny Devine / Havok / Johnny Devine (2004 - 2007 / 2007 - ?) |
| •Jackson James | played | Himself / Garett Bischoff (Referee 2010 - 2011 / 2011 - Present) |
| •Scott Reichsteiner | played | Scott Steiner (2002, 2003, 2006, 2007 - 2008) |
| •Robert Rechsteiner | played | Rick Steiner (2006 - February 2010 / January 2011 - ?) |
| •Dorian Hill | played | D-Ray 3000 (2004, 2006) |
| •Kazushi Miyamoto | played | Miyamoto (2004) |
| •Kazunari Nozawa | played | Nozawa (2004) |
| •Valerie Wyndham | played | So-Cal Val (Ring girl & Host of Pillow Talk - 2006 - ?) |
| •Matt Hyson | played | Brother Runt (2006 - 2007 / 2010) |
| •Monty Brown | played | 'The Alpha Male' Monty Brown (2004 - 2006) |
| •Chris Harris (2) | played | 'Wildcat' Chris Harris (2004 - January 11th 2008 / 2011 - ?) |
| •A.C. Connor | played | D'Lo Brown (2004) |
| •Héctor Garza | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Abismo Negro | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Sam Roman | played | Kid Romeo (2004 - 2005) |
| •Jose Seldano | played | Mr. Aguila (2004) |
| •Terry Gerin | played | Rhino / Rhyno (2005 - ?) |
| •Mark LaMonica | played | Brother Ray Deadly / Bully Ray (2005 - 2010 / 2010 - ?) |
| •Devon Hughes | played | Brother Devon Deadly / Devon / Sgt. at Arms (2005 - 2010 / 2010 - September 2012 / October 2012 - ?) |
| •Jim Mitchell (1) | played | James Mitchell (2004 - ?) |
| •Sonny Siaki | played | Himself (2004 - 2005) |
| •Kevin Nash | played | Himself (2004 - ?) |
| •Lex Lovett | played | Himself (2004 - 2006) |
| •Bobby Lashley | played | Himself (April 2009 - February 2010 / 9 March 2014 - ?) |
| •Jeremy Lynn | played | Jerry Lynn (2002 - 2007 / June 2011 - ?) |
| •Jason Messengale | played | Jason Cross (2004) |
| •Elliott Sadler | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Bruce Santee | played | Bruce Steele/Bruce Steel (2006) |
| •Rod Steele | played | Rod Steel/Rod Steele (2006) |
| •Eddie Villa | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Robert Strauss (2) | played | Robbie E (August 2010 - ?) |
| •Brandon Silvestry | played | Senshi (2006 / 2008 - ?) |
| •Jon Dalton | played | Jonny Fairplay (2004 - 2005) |
| •Joe Dorgan | played | Johnny Swinger (2004) |
| •Chris Lindsey (1) | played | Roderick Strong (2004 - 2006) |
| •Pat Kenney (1) | played | Simon Diamond / Road agent (2004 - 2006 / 2006 - ?) |
| •Ron Harris (1) | played | Himself (2004 - 2005) |
| •Don Harris (1) | played | Himself (2004 - 2005) |
| •Ken Shamrock | played | Himself (2004) |
| •David Santo | played | David Young (2004 - 2007) |
| •Jackie Gayda | played | Herself (2005 - 2006) |
| •Dallas Page | played | DDP / Diamond Dallas Page (2004 - 2005) |
| •Roddy Piper | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Dustin Runnels | played | Dustin Rhodes / Black Reign (2004 - 2005 / 2007 - ?) |
| •Sean Waltman | played | Syxx Pac / Sean Waltman (2002 / 2005 / 2010 - ?) |
| •Erik Watts | played | Himself (2004 - 2005) |
| •Charles Ashenoff | played | Konnan (2004 - 2007) |
| •Mark Haskins | played | Himself (2011 - ?) |
| •Stephanie Finochio | played | Trinity (2004 - 2005) |
| •Chris Candido | played | Himself (2005) |
| •Joseph Soria | played | Shocker (2005 - 2006) |
| •Jesse Sorensen | played | Himself (July 2011 - ?) |
| •Armando Quintero | played | Himself - Spanish commentator (2004 - 2005) |
| •Bruno Sassi | played | Himself (2005) |
| •Scott Hall | played | Himself (2002 / 2004 - 2005 / 2007 - ?) |
| •Joe Hitchen | played | Joe E. Legend / Legend (2004) |
| •Scott Hudson | played | Himself - Announcer (2004 - 2005) |
| •Brian Kendrick | played | Spanky / Brian Kendrick (2004 / 2010 - ?) |
| •Jacqueline Moore (1) | played | Jacqueline / Jackie Moore / Miss Jackie (2004 / 2004 / 2007 - ?) |
| •T.J. Perkins | played | Puma / Manik (2004, 2006 - 2009, 2012 / June 2013 - present) |
| •Buck Quartermain | played | Himself (2004 - 2006) |
| •Mikal Adryan | played | Judas / Murphy (June 2010 / July 2010 - ?) |
| •Matt Sydal | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Terry Taylor | played | Himself - Director of Talent Relations / Road agent (2004 - ?) |
| •Chad Lail | played | Shatter / Gunner (June 2010 / July 2010 - ?) |
| •Anthony Nese | played | Tony Nese (2011 - ?) |
| •Jimmy Hart (1) | played | Jimmy "Mouth of the South" Hart - Manager of the Nasty Boys (2004 - 2005 / 2010 - ?) |
| •Karen Angle | played | Herself (2007 - 2008 / January 2011 - ?) |
| •Nicole Raczynski | played | 'The Voodoo Queen' Roxxi Laveaux / Roxy Laveaux / Roxxi Laveaux / Roxxi (2007 - 2009) |
| •Alstair Ralphs | played | A - 1 (2005 - 2006) |
| •Big Tilly | played | Himself (2005) |
| •Tim Welch | played | Himself / Attorney Daggert (2004 / 2005 - 2006) |
| •Katrina Waters | played | Winter (October 2010 - ?) |
| •Nelson Erazo | played | Homicide (2005 - ?) |
| •Jamar Shipman | played | Jay Lethal / Black Machismo (2005 - 2006 / 2007 - ?) |
| •James Guffey | played | Jimmy Rave (2004) |
| •Travis Tomko | played | Tomko (2006 - ?) |
| •Matt Morgan (1) | played | Himself - Bodyguard / Enforcer / The Blue Print (2007 - 2008 / 2009 - ?) |
| •Adam Jones | played | 'Pacman' Jones (2007 - ?) |
| •Adam Flash | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Adolfo Tapia | played | L. A. Park (2004) |
| •Andrew Martin (1) | played | 'The Punisher' Andrew Martin (2007) |
| •Andrew Thomas (5) | played | Himself - Referee (2004 - ?) |
| •Angel Williams | played | Angel Williams / Angelina Love (2004 / 2007 - ?) |
| •Jonathan Rechner | played | Balls Mahoney (2004) |
| •Bob Armstrong | played | Himself (2005 - 2006) |
| •Bob Backlund | played | Himself (2007) |
| •Matt Striker | played | Matt Stryker (2004) |
| •Brian Wohl | played | Julio Dinero (2004) |
| •Bruce Gray (2) | played | Himself - Referee (2004) |
| •Cassidy O'Reilly | played | Cassidy Riley (2004 - 2006) |
| •Chris Kanyon | played | Chris K. / Kanyon (2005) |
| •Chris Vaughn | played | 'Live Wire' Chris Vaughn (2004) |
| •Crystal Louthan | played | Herself - Backstage Interviewer (2007 - ?) |
| •Jamie Szantyr | played | Talia Madison / Velvet Sky / Velvet Skye (2007 / 2007 - ?) |
| •Dan Hollie | played | Damaja (2007) |
| •Dave Hebner | played | Himself - Referee (2005 - ?) |
| •Earl Hebner | played | Himself - Referee (2006 - ?) |
| •David Taylor (3) | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Dean Allmark | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Dionico Castellanos | played | Psicosis (2004) |
| •Lisa Marie Varon | played | Tara (2009 - 16 May 2011 / 11 July 2011 - ?) |
| •Donovan Morgan | played | Himself (2006) |
| •Doug Basham | played | Basham (2007) |
| •Wayne Cowan | played | Himself as Dirty Dutch Mantel - Producer & Writer (2003 - ?) |
| •Edward Umar Fatu | played | Ekmo Fatu (2004) |
| •Erick Casas | played | Heavy Metal (2004) |
| •Sarah Stock | played | Sarita (2009 - ?) |
| •Harley Race | played | Himself (2007) |
| •Hector Guerrero | played | Himself - Spanish commentator / Road agent / Manager (2007 - ?) |
| •Hunter Johnston | played | Delirious (2004) |
| •Thea Trinidad | played | Rosita (2011 - ?) |
| •Jaime Dauncey | played | Jamie D / Sirelda (2006) |
| •Jaime Lynne | played | Lollipop (2004) |
| •Mikey Whipwreck | played | Himself (2004) |
| •James Fullington | played | Sandman (2004) |
| •Adam Birch | played | Joey Matthews (2004, 2007) |
| •Mark LeRoux | played | Lash LeRoux (2004) |
| •Jushin Liger | played | Jushin 'Thunder' Liger (2005 - 2006) |
| •Juventud Guerrera | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Matt Barela | played | Anarquia (March 2011 - ?) |
| •Kelly Wolfe | played | Slash (2004) |
| •Kenny Layne | played | Kenny King (2005 - 2006) |
| •Kevin Northcutt | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Kim Neilson | played | Desire (2004) |
| •Larry Pfohl | played | Lex Luger (2004, 2006) |
| •Marcus Bagwell | played | Himself (2006) |
| •Michael Modest | played | Himself (2006) |
| •Mitsunobu Kikuzawa | played | Kikutaro (2004) |
| •Nick Cvjetkovich | played | Sinn (2004 - 2005) |
| •Norman Smiley | played | 'Screamin' Norman Smiley (2006 - 2007) |
| •Peter Polaco | played | Justin Credible / P J Palaco (2005) |
| •Phil Brooks | played | C. M. Punk (2004) |
| •Ricky Banderas | played | Judas Mesias (2007 - ?) |
| •Ricky Vega | played | Himself / Machete (2007) |
| •Rocky Romero | played | Black Tiger IV (2006) |
| •Ryan Drago | played | Himself (2006) |
| •Joseph James Jr. | played | Scott Armstrong (Referee 2004) |
| •Shaggy 2 Dope | played | Insane Clown Posse (2004, 2006) |
| •Violent J | played | Insane Clown Posse (2004, 2006) |
| •Solofa Fatu Jr | played | Junior Fatu (2007) |
| •Stephanie Bellars | played | Minsa / Minza (2004) |
| •Teddy Hart (2) | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Terry Funk | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Tyson Tux | played | 'Textbook' Tyson Tux (2006) |
| •Veronica Stevens | played | Nurse Veronica (2004) |
| •Vito LoGrasso | played | Big Vito (2004) |
| •Jessica Kresa | played | ODB (2007 - ?) |
| •Kia Stevens | played | The Amazon Kong / Awesome Kong (2007 - 2008 / 2008 - ?) |
| •Shelly Martinez | played | Herself (2007 / 2008 - ?) |
| •Talia Madison | played | Herself (2007 - ?) |
| •Willie Urbina | played | Himself - Spanish Broadcaster (2006 - ?) |
| •Jack Melendez | played | Himself as 'Moody' Jack Melendez - Spanish Broadcaster (2004 - 2006) |
| •John Hugger | played | Rellik (2007 - ?) |
| •Rob Terry | played | Rob Terry / Robbie T / The Freak (2009 - 2011 / 2012 - 2014 / 2014 - ?) |
| •Sharmell Sullivan | played | Sharmell (2007 - ?) |
| •Alexa Thatcher | played | Alexa Jade (2007 - ?) |
| •Bonnie Maxon | played | Ms. Banks / Peyton Banks / Miss Payton Banks (2007 - ?) |
| •Austin Watson | played | Austin Creed / Rasheed Lucius 'Consequences' Creed (2008 - ?) |
| •Chris Melendez | played | Himself (August 2014 - ?) |
| •Cathy Dingman | played | Taylor Vaughn (2002) |
| •Leilani Kai | played | Herself (2003) |
| •Madison | played | Herself (2003) |
| •Donna Adamo | played | Elektra (2002) |
| •Francine Fournier | played | Francine (2002) |
| •Shannon Spruill-Ward | played | Sarah Palin / Daffney (2008 - 2009 / 2009 - ?) |
| •April Pennington | played | April Pennington / April (2002 / 2003) |
| •Daizee Haze | played | Daisy Haze (2003 / 2008 - ?) |
| •Shinsuke Nakamura | played | Himself (2008 - ?) |
| •Yoshihiro Yamazaki | played | Tiger Mask / Tiger Mask IV (2008 - ?) |
| •Hermie Sadler | played | Himself - Play-by-Play announcer (2008 - ?) |
| •Shane Sewell | played | Himself - Referee (2008 - ?) |
| •Cheerleader Melissa | played | Raisha Saeed / Cheerleader Melissa / Raisha Saeed (2008 - ?) |
| •Temptress | played | Herself (2008 - ?) |
| •Taylor Wilde | played | Herself (2008 - ?) |
| •Trenesha Biggers | played | Rhaka Khan (2008 - ?) |
| •Mickie Knuckles | played | Moose Knuckles (2008 - ?) |
| •Frank Trigg | played | Himself (2008 - ?) |
| •Jeff Jarrett | played | Himself (June 2002 - October 2006 & April 2007 - December 2013) |
| •Dusty Rhodes | played | Himself - Director of Authority (2004 - 2005) |
| •Lawrence Whistler | played | Larry Zbyszko / Director of Authority (2004 / 2005 - 2006) |
| •Leticia Cline | played | Herself - Backstage Interviewer (2006 - 2007) |
| •Akira Kawabata | played | Akira Raijin / Kiyoshi / Suicide / Kiyoshi (18 December 2008 - 16 February 2010 / 14 June - October 2010 / October 2010 - January 2012) |
| •Alex Silva | played | Himself |
| •Amber O'Neal | played | Herself (April - May 2006 & December 2009) |
| •Andy Douglas | played | Himself (2004 - 2007) |
| •Austin Aries | played | Himself (2005 - 2006 / 2006 - 2007) |
| •Ayako Hamada | played | Hamada (27 August 2009 - December 2010) |
| •Booker Huffman | played | Booker T. (2007 - 2009) |
| •Brad Bradley | played | Jay Bradley (2013 - present) |
| •Brian Knobs | played | Himself as The Nasty Boys (2010 - ?) |
| •Brian Hebner | played | Himself (Referee) |
| •Brutus Magnus | played | Magnus (2009 - 2011) |
| •Bubba The Love Sponge | played | Himself - Backstage interviewer (2009 - ?) |
| •Chase Stevens | played | Himself (2004 - 2007) |
| •Chelsea | played | Herself - Valet of Desmond Wolfe / Manager of Desmond Wolfe & Magnus (January - August 2010) |
| •Cody Deaner | played | Himself (2009 - ?) |
| •Dale Torborg | played | Himself (2005 - 2007) |
| •Don Callis | played | Himself - Management Consultant (2003 - 2004) |
| •Doug Williams (4) | played | Himself (2009 - ?) |
| •Drew Hankinson | played | Himself (September 2012 - ?) |
| •Elijah Samuel Burke | played | Pope D'Angelo Dinero (2009 - ?) |
| •Eric Bischoff | played | Himself (Booker - October 2009 - April 2012) |
| •Francisco Ciatso | played | Frankie Capone / Francisco Ciatso (2006 / 2007) |
| •Germán Figueroa | played | El Leon (The Lion) / Apollo / Gran Apollo / Apollo (2004 / 2004 / 2005 / 2006) |
| •Glen Gilbertti | played | Glen Gilbertti / Disco Inferno (2002 - 2004 / 2007) |
| •Hulk Hogan | played | Hulk Hogan - Co-Owner & President of TNA (November 2009 - 3 October 2013) |
| •Jack Miller (2) | played | Himself (2004 - 2005) |
| •James Curtin | played | Rockstar Spud (January 2012 / January 2013 - present) |
| •James E. Cornette | played | Himself (Management Director - 2006 - 2009) |
| •Jason Reso | played | Christian Cage (2005 - 2009) |
| •Jenna Morasca | played | Herself (2009 - 2009) |
| •Jerry Sags | played | Himself as The Nasty Boys (2010 - ?) |
| •Jesse Neal | played | Himself (2009 - ?) |
| •Joanie Laurer | played | Chyna (2011 - 2011) |
| •Joseph Meehan | played | Joey Ryan (May 2012 - ?) |
| •Josette Bynum | played | Sojourner Bolt (2009 - ?) |
| •Kazuchika Okada | played | Okada (16 February 2010 - October 2011) |
| •Keiji Mutoh | played | The Great Muta (11 March 2007 / 9 March 2014) |
| •Ken Anderson (2) | played | Mr. Anderson (2010 - ?) |
| •Kimberly Whitehead | played | Kimberly (2008) |
| •Kiyoshi | played | Himself (2009 - ?) |
| •Lacey Von Erich | played | Herself (2009 - 2011) |
| •Lauren Brooke | played | Herself (Backstage Interviewer - 2008 - 2011) |
| •Marc Mero | played | Johnny B. Badd (November 2004 - 2005) |
| •Matt Massie | played | Himself (2009 - ?) |
| •Michael Manna | played | Dr. Stevie (2009 - ?) |
| •Mick Foley | played | Mick Foley (Network Consultant - 2009 - 2010 / 2011 - 2011) |
| •Mike Hettinga | played | Knux (May 2012 - present) |
| •Nick Massie | played | Himself / Jeremy Buck (2009 - 2009 / 2010 - ?) |
| •Orlando Jordan | played | Himself (2010 - ?) |
| •Quinton Jackson | played | Rampage Jackson |
| •Randy Savage | played | Himself (2004) |
| •Ric Flair | played | Himself (Manager of "Immortal" - 2010 - May 2012) |
| •Rob Szatkowski | played | Rob Van Dam / RVD (8 March 2010 - March 2013) |
| •Ron Killings | played | Ron 'The Truth' Killings (June 2002 - December 2007) |
| •Rubix | played | Himself |
| •Ryan Wilson (2) | played | Titus / Trytan (2004 - 2005 / 2005) |
| •Salvador Guerrero, Jr. | played | Chavo Guerrero Jr. (July 2012 - ?) |
| •Sam Shaw (2) | played | Himself / Samuel Shaw (August - December 2010 & November 2012 - June 2013 / November 2013 - ?) |
| •Scott D'Amore | played | Coach D'Amore / Booker (2004 / 2005) |
| •Sean Morley | played | Morley (4 January - March 2010) |
| •Shawn Daivari | played | King Abdul Bashir (2008 - 2010) |
| •Steve Borden | played | Sting (2005 - 2014) |
| •Steven Haworth | played | Desmond Wolfe (2009 - ?) |
| •Tommy Mercer | played | Little Red / Crimson (December 2010 / January 2011 - 2014) |
| •Trevor Rhodes | played | "The Outlaw" Jethro Holliday (2009 - ?) |
| •Wesley Brisco | played | Wes Brisco (September 2012 - ?) |
| •Zach Gowen | played | Zach Gowan/Zach Gowen (2005 - 2006) |