Login or register

Game of Dominions (The ‘Dominion’ Review)

Dominion Cast

Wow. That was... surprisingly good. Better than I expected from what appeared to be one part knockoff of ‘Game of Thrones’, one part knockoff of ‘Supernatural’, and one part knockoff of ‘Defiance’.

But first, because it’s kind of confusing, let’s see what the hell (or heaven) is going on.

Seen the movie ‘Legion’? If not, don’t worry, neither did anybody else. Fortunately, there’s a big voiceover intro at the beginning of the episode to tell us that most of the lower angels decided to wipe out Man. One of their archangels, Michael, sided with Man instead of Angel, helped them defend themselves, and Man built strongholds to keep the angels out. The head of the bad angels is Gabriel, and helping him are lesser angels that can only appear on Earth by possessing humans. So basically, ‘Supernatural’.

There’s a prophecy of a Chosen One, a child who will help Man defeat Angel once and for all. No one knows who the child is, and it seems like many of the human survivors have embraced him as a religious figure.

That’s the back story. The front story is set in the walled Vega, formerly Las Vegas. Two family houses, the Riesen and the Whele, control the place. It’s not quite a dictatorship, but there’s a strict caste system and poverty lives down a short distance from vast wealth and power.

And then there’s Alex Lannon, the maverick soldier who doesn’t play by the rules. He serves as part of Michael’s corps of soldiers and is in love with Claire Riesen, the daughter of General Riesen (Alan Dale, 'Lost'). Vaguely opposing Riesen at least at first is David Whele (Anthony Stewart Head from ‘Buffy’, with an annoying American accent). David has a son, William, who is an uppity-upp in the local religious organization. He's a true believer, while Dave is not.

Anthony Stewart Head as David Whele

And living out in a tower is Michael, who spends his nights hanging out with lots of naked women. The most prominent is Becca Thorn, another member of the ruling class who is the leading scientist. Apparently Michael likes angel sex but not spawning half-angel children.

Gabriel is still around and planning an assault, and finally has non-possessing angels on his side. They can get into Vega without being detected. How? Security guards have possession scanners, but these angels don’t possess humans. Gabriel also has a mole in Vega and the unwitting help of David, who is trying to undermine the city so that he can step in as its new protector.

And the Chosen One has been revealed. Look at the list of characters above and try to guess which one it is.

Got all that? Good. Basically, ‘Dominion’ is a strange mix of ‘Supernatural’ angels and ‘Mad Max’ post-apocalyptic landscapes. Throw in Houses at each other’s throat and you get ‘Game of Thrones’. And the whole “a settlement of mixed types rebuilding after a war and disasters” thing is a lot like Syfy’s other series, ‘Defiance’. Which airs right before ‘Dominion’.

Despite what seems like a car crash of mash-ups, ‘Dominion’ actually works pretty well. Part of it is the cinematography, which uses the South African actors, sets, and exteriors to good effect. There’s an after-the-apocalypse feel that you don’t get with ‘Defiance’.

I’ve heard complaints about the special effects, but they seemed fine to me for your average genre weekly TV show. There seems to be a lot of money tossed at this show.

The actors are mostly forgettable. No one is too offensive, no one is out-acting the others. Tom Wisdom as Michael is probably the standout actor, but he gets to play the inhuman angel guy so he just stands around and glowers a lot. Chris Egan is the Joe Average guy, the audience POV character.

Chris Egan as Alex Lannon

There's some brief coed barracks nudity in the shower (think 'Starship Troopers') but if there were any sexual situations, I must have missed them. The preceding season 2 premiere of 'Defiance' had more sexual situations, with handjobs and bathtub orgasms.

The main reason I rate 'Dominion' pretty highly is because it's the kind of show that makes you want to keep watching. What was the war like? What did Riesen and David do during the war? How was Michael involved? What's a war against angels like? Why doesn't Michael want to have children?

I also like the fact that it's not just a fantasy show, but a religious fantasy show. It looks like they're going to take a look at what it means to have an angel in your midst, training your armies and wanting sex. Or a savior. Claire, for instance, just discovered she's been dating the guy that she has been unwittingly worshipping for years.

The mix of technology and fantasy is also kind of appealing. I find the idea of Michael wearing an earpiece, for instance, kind of amusing.

Tom Wisdom as Michael in Dominion

After watching this and 'Defiance' on the same night, you get the impression that the Syfy execs have finally noticed that 'Game of Thrones' is doing well and decided to spend more money on both shows. 'Defiance' gave us two new cities, 'Dominion' gave us a whole world. With 'Wil Wheaton Project' (Tuesday nights, check it out), and 26 episodes of 'Haven' coming later this summer, SyFy might actually have a decent slate of programming this summer.

So check it out, you might actually like it. Thursday, 9/8 central.

- Dominion
- Tom Wisdom
- Chris Egan
- Anthony Stewart Head
- Syfy

Written by: Van Troughton
Jun 20th, 2014, 11:10 pm

Images courtesy of Syfy


Level 1 (9%)
Since: 27/Jun/14
Message Posted On Jun 27th, 2014, 4:47 pm

Game of empty throne.  It's disappointing to have such a weak portrayal of such powerful creatures.  Supernatural's treatment is appropriate to the context of its respective mythos. 




Level 1 (23%)
Since: 11/Sep/08
Message Posted On Jun 24th, 2014, 6:16 pm

May have already been asked, but where you state: "Part of it is the cinematography, which uses the South African actors, sets, and exteriors to good effect." Who exactly are you referring to as being South African? Majority of the main casting is English (Tom Wisdon; Luke Allen-Dale; Athony Head and Rosalind Halstead) Alan Dale is New Zealander, Roxanne McKee is Canadian and Chris Egan is Australian.

Yes, Carl Beukes (Gabriel) is South African actor; are you then saying that he is the only good actor in the whole show? I'm referring to the main cast here. 

(Site Moderator)

Level 100 (74%)
Points: 179471.6
Mood: frustrated
Since: 13/Dec/05
Message Posted On Jun 24th, 2014, 6:39 am

"Again, apologies if it appeard as if I was taking a stab at you or any of the sites staff."


No offense assumed or taken.



"oooh, I think I'd rather go with the critics and not even bother."



I wouldn't advise letting any critic's analysis deter you from watching a show if it sounds appealing to you. If it doesn't, then it doesn't.


Level 2 (45%)
Since: 19/Jun/11
Message Posted On Jun 22nd, 2014, 10:45 pm

This really isn't a debate as to whether the show is any good or not -- some will like it, most will not -- while that's all being sorted out, opinions will be shared :-)


Message Posted On Jun 22nd, 2014, 3:47 pm
@gadfly, that wasn't aimed at you or any of the sites staff AT ALL. I am sorry if it appeared that way. By "critics" I mean those self proclaimed know it all types that write completely moronic reviews for the sake of beeing talked about for big media such as "USA today". The type that reads about a new show, in his/her mind compares it to some classic literature and then starts raging about the show in the most destructive language you could print because it's not a theatrical Shakespeare drama or a reading of Goethe's best. Hence the comparisn of driving a beetle and complaining about the experience not beeing something completely diffrent (better?). Again, apologies if it appeard as if I was taking a stab at you or any of the sites staff.

Level 2 (85%)
Since: 12/Oct/07
Message Posted On Jun 22nd, 2014, 2:29 pm

oooh, I think I'd rather go with the critics and not even bother.

(Site Moderator)

Level 100 (74%)
Points: 179471.6
Mood: frustrated
Since: 13/Dec/05
Message Posted On Jun 21st, 2014, 8:48 pm

As far as what critics say... well, I don't consider myself a critic. I'm just a guy here to tell my fellow TVRagers (TVRagites?) in understandable English why I liked a show, and describe the basics of what is going on. I don't expect anyone to agree with me. If you don't like the kind of show I'm describing, glad I saved you some time. If you gave it a shot and found it boring, more power to you.

Still, if you check the shows I edit, you'll see that I tend to follow a lot of the shows of the genre. For what it's worth, right now I consider it good enough to keep watching. It could crash and burn in two episodes, but until then, I'll keep viewing.

(Site Moderator)

Level 100 (74%)
Points: 179471.6
Mood: frustrated
Since: 13/Dec/05
Message Posted On Jun 21st, 2014, 8:05 pm

*shrug* I didn't find the backstory particularly cumbersome. There was a war between Heaven and Man, it's at a standstill, the angels are preparing a new assault, there's a Chosen One human guy. That's it, really.

I'd admit, they could have compressed and/or skipped some stuff and kept the pilot to 1 hour. But then there'd be people complaining that they didn't explain enough. In my experience, most pilots could be considered boring. Lots of exposition, lots of character introductions.


Message Posted On Jun 21st, 2014, 4:32 pm
You ppl need to relearn what it means to be entertained by something, what entertainment is. If you want high flying intellectual challenges go visit a library or watch the science channel. Especially when I read what so called critics have to say about a new show or a movie I often wonder what it is these ppl are expecting and why they still have a job considering by how far they usually miss the mark. It's like driving a volkswagon beetle and expecting it to be a formula one racecare experience and then complain the hell out of it because their expectations weren't met.

Level 1 (37%)
Since: 04/Feb/14
Message Posted On Jun 21st, 2014, 11:51 am

I have to agree with chaznet.  The brief description I read of it intrigued me and I tried watching this.  I'm afraid I didn't make it to the 30-minute mark before I decided I had enough.  I barely got to the fifteen minute mark.  :)

I guess that's what is so great about television.  There is something out there to appeal to everyone.  What I might find boring and poorly written, someone else might find to be exciting and inspired and vice versa. 

Related news

Being Human Season Two Teaser Trailer

Being Human returns January 16th to the SYFY channel in the US. The..

"Paranormal Witness" Renewed By Syfy

Paranormal Witness, Syfy's documdrama series has been renewed by network..

Monster Man Premieres March 14 on SyFy

Syfy is getting ready to premiere its new docuseries Monster Man in March...
Discuss Dominion